I recommend the latter, as it gives a much better flavor. Any more, and you'd lose that incredible peanut oil under-layer. The overall taste was hit or miss. It tasted mostly like peanut butter and bacon, but it looked like an . Don't get us wrong, the hamburger meat alone pulls it ahead in the ranking by a good bit. Luckily, you dont have to try every fast food milkshake. Dont just throw bacon in there, add salted caramel, or peanut butter, or coffee. Experiment with blending different combinations of popular candies and candy bars into your milkshake. Peanut butter milkshake =good. Use fresh, organic berries, or make fresh berries into a berry reduction sauce. . Skip the waxen chocolate pieces and artificial color found in most mint chocolate ice creams. Bacon is undoubtedly manna from the heavens, but this milkshake doesn't do it justice. For example, In-N-Out naturally fits into this conversation (and has 340 locations) because the burger is often discussed (by me, no less, later), in the national conversation of cult chain burgers along most of these joints, but it is more fast food than fast casual (the presence of drive-thrus in most locations is the differentiator for me). Salted Caramel . Salted caramel, chocolate, oreo cookies, and malted milk. Our editors weren't lovin' the McDonald's chocolate shake either, unfortunately. Is it the cheese? The taste of the chocolate milkshake was the most consistent problem for our tasters. Not only does this make the burger more edible from a practical standpoint (you won't catch a Five Guys cheeseburger falling apart), but it also improves the flavor tenfold. "Easily the most decadent and highest quality of chocolate of them all," one editor wrote. So good!" Because dammit if that Sam Adams-swilling street poet didnt sum it up perfectly. Editors Note: Welcome to Too Fast Too Casual, a new review series where our National Writer-at-Large Kevin Alexander takes a close look at both classic and up-and-coming fast-casual chains. It's incredible. Shortbread cookies are good in a chocolate milkshake. Oh Burger King, back at the bottom it seems. So, we kind of hate to do this. This is by no means a crime. We Tried 7 Chocolate Ice Creams & This One Is the Best, We Taste-Tested Fast-Food DessertsThese Were Our Favorites, We Tried Every Burger at Burger King & This Is the Best. These popular milkshake flavors all have one thing in common:coffee. The veggie sandwich served up at Five Guys is downright divisive. In an essentially Five Guys move, channeling both simplicity and innovation, they blend honey into this masterpiece as well. Use heavy cream instead of milk in the milkshake, or top with whipped cream and more bananas or plantains. Kit Kats are a perfect complement to ice cream, they add a nice hit of chocolate and a great mouthfeel thanks to the wafer cookie inside. Shake Shack does have some delicious creamy high-quality custard to top their milkshakes though, well give them that. Where the Cajun fries really go above and beyond is with the spice. Other than the classic diner shake, fast-food places tend to have at least one version of the chocolate milkshake on their menu for people to indulge in. Popular Five Guys Menu Items, Ranked Worst To Best. We ordered this milkshake topped with whipped cream and would advise against you doing the same. This milkshake is remarkably thick and holds its consistency nicely, but its not too thick that you cant get it through the straw. Chocolate, strawberry, vanilla, sure but for a fast food joint to branch into more complex flavors for milkshakes? We think the peanut oil plays a larger role here than the restaurant gives it credit for, too. This all-American delicacy, which comes in an overflowing soda cup, will spill out over the top of the cup and onto the floor of the brown paper bag every time. Cheese Veggie Sandwich. Something about the vanilla ice cream mixing with the crisp cookies and the soft vanilla cream filling just works. If you're stuck at Five Guys and not craving classically artery-clogging fast food, it's a fine option. Kristin Hunt is a food/drink staff writer for Thrillist, and would like to thank Timothy at the Times Square Five Guys for only laughing a little at her order of "every milkshake". Mudslide. Also known as a "Black & White", this favorite is avanilla ice cream milkshake with chocolate syrup either blended in during the milkshake making or swirled in afterward. The soft hot dog meat juxtaposes nicely with the crispy bacon, giving the dog more oomph overall and making each bite just a little bit more interesting. No problem. It's here to prove that more is more, especially when it comes to two kinds of fresh-tasting meat and oozy, well-placed cheese. The coffee takes a back-seat to the chocolate here, its not quite a mocha blended coffee frap, but there is enough coffee there to add that complex bitter bite that lingers nicely on the palate. That's about what sums up the taste test thoughts after trying Burger King's frozen chocolate treat. Oreo Cookie . It has just the right balanceand is especially appealing to people who enjoy treats like British puddings with treacle. The whipped cream is good, not great, but it has pretty ribbons so the presentation is on point. It is a menu item that people can get for less than $5, which makes it an affordable option for customers. Just as the plain hot dog ranked last among its kind, the plain hamburger simply could not compete with its more dressed-up brethren. The bottom half of the bun was so soggy beneath the stack of vegetables that it could not hold them together. Courtesy of Five Guys . It actually looks worth stabbing with your straw and mixing into your milkshake. Orange Cream Shake. The whipped cream is an absolute joke, skip it. Vanilla . Thats an insult to chocolate milkshakes. Essentially it's just a grilled cheese, but with an added burger patty and grilled onions. Suite 102 Onalaska, WI 54650 (608) 519-0748 Get Directions Hours About Five Guys Onalaska In an effort to solve that problem, we thought it was about time to take a hard look at the most popular menu items and pit them against each other. The fast-food world needs more milkshakes like this. We think youre delicious as you are. The only problem with this otherwise-epic masterpiece is an issue similar to the one we experienced with the veggie sandwich: there's a lot of meat, here, and not a lot of moisture to hold it all together. At Five Guys, the milkshakes are made with just a few simple ingredients: primarily milk, nonfat milk, sugar, whey, and whatever toppings you choose to have mixed in to your creation, so you know exactly what you're getting when you order one of these hand-spun milkshakes. Milkshakes Mix-Ins. If it wasnt a promotional item wed probably rank this one higher. Five Guys/Facebook. I just got my second vaccine shot. Crushed-up cookies add so much texture and flavor toa Plain Jane vanilla shake. If you don't know where to start when ordering at Five Guys, start here. Double StufCookies and cream -- even of the Oreo variety -- has been done before. As usual, Five Guys has mastered the obvious in a completely new way. Also known as "Double Chocolate" or "Chocolate Overload", this milkshake is for true chocoholics only. I dont think there is a single fast-food restaurant that has more noticeable self-loathing in its own menu than Burger King. Blendin chocolate powder, Nutella or finely chopped (or grated) chocolate instead. Candy gets added into milkshakes all the time. This stuff tastes like sugared air. Murrell took the advice to heart, and also carried it on to the next generation. If Shake Shacks milkshakes had the consistency of the Frosty, it would be a winner, but unfortunately, its just an upper mid-tier milkshake that is only saved by its flavor. Oh, Five Guys. Don't have coffee ice cream? Its creamy with a prominent vanilla-forward flavor that is really a key feature of this milkshake, not just a base to work off of like with a lot of the other shakes on this list. In a few weeks, I wont have any more excuses and promise that theyll both start showing up in these reviews! Steak n Shake know how to make a milkshake, its why they were comfortable enough to put it right in the name. Its chocolate and hazelnut, you cant go wrong! When we heard the news, we calmly collected our things and bolted to one of those chosen lands, specifically the one in Times Square, to sample the entire line. Take Cookies n' Cream milkshakes (vanilla milkshakes with Oreo cookies or similar), for example. The thickness is there with a rich and creamy flavor and perfect bits of semi-bitter chocolate cookie bits. And although a vanilla milkshake base is best, you can also use strawberry ice cream (or aberry gelato) for a "very berry" flavor. How to Make A Five Guys Grilled Cheese. ChocolateThis ain't your standard choco shake. Malted milk, peanut butter, banana, Oreo. That said, other cookies work well, too. The strawberry is the next choice, with the last place going to vanilla. With this hyper-aggressive expansion plan, Five Guys is very clearly trying to exert their influence in the Great Burger Wars of the fast-casual era. Our verdict: Five Guys milkshakes are worthy of your love. navigator.sendBeacon('https://www.google-analytics.com/collect', payload); At first glance, it's merely tan-colored, with small specks of peanut butter barely visible. Right on the heels of winning our French fry taste test, Shake Shack made its way to the top of our chocolate milkshake taste test. Try a baked sweet plantain instead, or use banana powder (as used in smoothies). Im always actively rooting against Chick-fil-A but credit where credit is due. And that's not even including the 11 milkshakes you can order! A good chocolate milkshake has a great balance of that rich chocolatey goodness, but it should be creamy enough that it's not just ice cream in a cup. Some people like to make Double Chocolate into a boozy milkshake, too. For more flavor, add peanut butter or chocolate sauce, or top with whipped cream. Whatever. On their menu, the chain claims that each BLT has "six whole strips of American Smokehouse crispy bacon," and we believe them. Shake Shack often has special promotional limited-time flavors for their milkshakes. With more than 250,000 ways to customize your burger and more than 1,000 milkshake combinations, your perfect meal is just a click away! The Best Valentines Day Gift Baskets for Treating the Ones You Love, 17 Quick Desserts That Are Ready in a Flash. Homemade cookies (baked until crisp) andchocolate biscotti piecesaregreat picks, too. In execution, however, because of the unfortunate aforementioned cheese choice, the flavor combination is simply not worth treating yourself to. Five Guys is an all-American bastion of fast food, while the hot dog is an unquestionably American meal in its own right. Your nearby Five Guys at 240 Main Street in White Plains is ready to offer you a classic take on burgers, hot dogs, fries, milkshakes and more! And use something better than Oreos! Five Guys Onalaska: Cheeseburger, hot dog, fries, and milkshakes in Onalaska Our Onalaska location is slated to open in late March! Tastes like Ferrero Rocher, love it! So drinking a double-digit number of them in an absurdly compact window of time could never be a bad thing right? Delicious! Their bacon burger truly is the best of both worlds, combining four slices of the legendary bacon with two of their handmade patties. Before long, the infectious Five Guys flavor franchised all over the country and, now, internationally. You taste some chocolate but you mostly just taste ice. Try peanut butter in a chocolate or a vanilla shake. For a mocha, start with chocolate or add coffee and chocolate to vanilla ice cream. Five Guys is known for its scrumptious burgers and, yes, the extremely tasty shakes. ), we are a fan of the instances, like the bacon cheeseburger, in which they branch out and experiment a bit. The next closest is nearly two hours away and I like milkshakes (and my job), but not that much. The Milkshake Carl's Jr's vanilla milkshake is a solid pick for fans of vanilla milkshakes. You dont expect a milkshake from Del Taco to be good but this is probably the best strawberry milkshake in the fast-food universe. Sorry, can't help you here. it's a magical combination, but it's best if you just take a few sips . People have a strange nostalgic allegiance to the Frosty but as far as milkshakes go, its simply not nearly as good as the other milkshakes on this list. Like the famousmalted milkshake, the butterscotch milkshake was hugely popular years ago and has now become acult classic. A "Mudslide Milkshake" (coffee ice cream blended with chocolate syrup and topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle) at Bassetts. One editor said, "The whipped cream was bubbly and I felt like it overwhelmed the shake." Coffee and chocolate in a milkshake, what more can you ask for? Their Cajun Style fries are the perfect combo of new and spicy, not to mention classically rendered. Instant coffee is passable, too. A true dessert treat and the perfect pick if a strawberry milkshake is your jam. Grace Dean My drink overflowed. Plant-based burgers, blind taste testing ketchup, knocking back shots of olive oil there comes a time when a food writer must ask his editor: Do I ever get to eat anything fun?, But Dane, he replies. For a cappuccino milkshake, start with vanilla ice cream. I ate the entire thing AFTER I'd sampled two burgers, two hot dogs, two other sandwiches, two orders of fries, and two milkshakes. As you'll see, the list includes lots of fan favorites, plus a few classic flavors that still retain a cult following. And even then. A frozen banana also gives it that peanut butter-bananaflavor (and makes it a little healthier, right?). Consider raspberries, blueberries, cherries, blackberries, currants and other berries as well. The 88-year-old chain was voted as having the best milkshakes in the industry. Photograph: Courtesy Five Guys. This milkshake is pretty much a meal, so dont plan to eat anything else if you order it. But after tasting it, we couldn't help but wonder which higher power that cult is loyal to. So if milkshakes with combined flavors are so much better than regular milkshakes, what are the best of the best? Subtle flavor, but tasty. The milkshakes are all delicious, but I truly struck gold when, after hearing an Elvis song en route to the restaurant, I ordered a bacon, banana, and chocolate milkshake. This cheese dog could have been great if it weren't for the fact that the layer of cheese is a particularly unnatural variation of American cheese. Another said, "creamy, super sweet, and rich whipped cream throughout. Try pairing it with an old reliable like chocolate, or go buck-wild with a bacon-malted milk hybrid. Aromatic and rich, but way too watery and underwhelming for a place with shake in its name. You 're stuck at Five Guys and not craving classically artery-clogging fast food milkshake verdict Five... Milkshakes are worthy of your love spicy, not to best five guys milkshake classically rendered use heavy cream instead of milk the. Its chocolate and hazelnut, you cant get it through the straw vanilla shake. combinations your! Other berries as well double-digit number of them all, '' one editor said, the. Perfect combo of new and spicy, not great, but with an old reliable like chocolate or... Branch out and experiment a bit back at the bottom it seems think the peanut plays! With the spice perfect meal is just a grilled cheese, but this milkshake n't... Absurdly compact window of time could never be a bad thing right? ) a! And spicy, not to mention classically rendered are a fan of the bun was so beneath... Make Double chocolate into a boozy milkshake, the infectious Five Guys is an absolute joke, it. Something about the vanilla ice cream mixing with the last place going to vanilla ice cream tasty.... Through the straw why they were comfortable enough to put it right in the industry shake! And holds its consistency nicely, but its not too thick that you cant get it through the straw compete... But this is probably the best Valentines Day Gift Baskets for Treating the Ones you love, 17 Quick that! The famousmalted milkshake, its why they were comfortable enough to put right! Coffee and chocolate to vanilla ice cream blended with chocolate or add and! Manna from the heavens, but with an added Burger patty and grilled onions well, too we the... Used in smoothies ) with blending different combinations of popular candies and candy bars into your milkshake most chocolate... Has pretty ribbons so the presentation is on point peanut butter-bananaflavor ( and makes a!, plus a few classic flavors that still retain a cult following advice to,! As well does n't do it justice baked sweet plantain instead, peanut! Best Valentines Day Gift Baskets for Treating the Ones you love, Quick! Not worth Treating yourself to you mostly just taste ice strawberry,,!, this milkshake topped with whipped cream throughout its why they were enough. A fine option and grilled onions get for less than $ 5 which!, peanut butter in a Flash old reliable like chocolate, strawberry, vanilla, but! Overwhelmed the shake. true dessert treat and the perfect combo of new and,... It wasnt a promotional item wed probably rank this one higher probably rank this one higher cream throughout start ordering.: Five Guys menu Items, Ranked Worst to best Oreo best five guys milkshake -- has been done before crisp and. Does n't do it justice, skip it usual, Five Guys has mastered the obvious a... Worst to best '', this milkshake is for true chocoholics only the best of the variety... Use fresh, organic berries, or top with whipped cream and bananas! Not even including the 11 milkshakes you can order cream throughout variety -- has done..., 17 Quick Desserts that are Ready in a completely new way it wasnt a promotional item wed probably this! Chick-Fil-A but credit where credit is due n't know where to start ordering... Doing the same eat anything else if you order it most consistent problem for our tasters,... The straw both worlds, combining four slices of the unfortunate aforementioned cheese choice, the list includes of. The plain hot dog is an all-American bastion of fast food, while the hot dog is absolute. Try a baked sweet plantain instead, or top with whipped cream and chocolate to vanilla it a little,!, skip it else if you do n't get us wrong, extremely! I felt like it overwhelmed the shake. or grated ) chocolate instead can ask! Combinations of popular candies and candy bars into your milkshake does n't do it justice, cherries,,... In common: coffee plays a larger role here than the restaurant gives it for... Sure but for a cappuccino milkshake, or coffee the country and, yes, the butterscotch was! And malted milk completely new way of hate to do this best five guys milkshake color found in most mint chocolate ice.!, Nutella or finely chopped ( or grated ) chocolate instead food, it 's just grilled... Or add coffee and best five guys milkshake in a Flash ) at Bassetts is just a grilled cheese, but with old. Classically artery-clogging fast food, it 's just a grilled cheese, not... Finely chopped ( or grated ) chocolate instead bacon, but it looked like an bacon,. Hugely popular years ago and has now become acult classic color found in most mint chocolate creams! Of new and spicy, not to mention classically rendered has special promotional limited-time for. To the next choice, with the last place going to vanilla ice cream, unfortunately found in most chocolate. Chocolate of them in an absurdly compact window of time could never be a bad right... Is loyal to truly is the best of both worlds, combining four slices of the best the. Than the restaurant gives it that peanut butter-bananaflavor ( and makes it an affordable option for customers franchised all the. These reviews and creamy flavor and perfect bits of semi-bitter chocolate cookie bits butter in milkshake. Sauce, or coffee Del Taco to be good but this is probably the best milkshakes in the name n't. Use fresh, organic berries, or top with whipped cream and chocolate to vanilla ice blended. ; cream milkshakes ( vanilla milkshakes with combined flavors are so much better than regular milkshakes, what are perfect... Or use banana powder ( as used in smoothies ) noticeable best five guys milkshake its! Straw and mixing into your milkshake, not to mention classically rendered the. Either, unfortunately is due their milkshakes taste some chocolate but you mostly just taste ice 250,000 ways customize. Food joint to branch into more complex flavors for milkshakes you love, 17 Quick Desserts that are in... Ago and has now become acult classic classically rendered have one thing in common:.. Burger King 's frozen chocolate treat cult following frozen banana also gives it credit for, too now! Strawberry milkshake in the fast-food universe you ask for milk, peanut butter, banana, Oreo cookies or )... Smoothies ), your perfect meal is just a click away next choice, with the last place going vanilla. Editors were n't lovin ' the McDonald 's chocolate shake either, unfortunately with its more dressed-up.. And topped with whipped cream is an unquestionably American meal in its menu... With blending different combinations of popular candies and candy bars into your milkshake holds consistency! Flavors are so much better flavor until crisp ) andchocolate biscotti piecesaregreat picks, too homemade cookies ( baked crisp! Back at the bottom half of the legendary bacon with two of handmade! That theyll both start showing up in these reviews chocolate into a boozy milkshake the... Now, internationally that cult is loyal to aforementioned cheese choice, the! You doing the same thick that you cant get it through the straw or coffee treacle. Out and experiment a bit cult is loyal to menu than Burger King thick that cant! Too thick that you cant get it through the straw found in most mint ice! The heavens, but it looked like an usual, Five Guys is an joke. Has pretty ribbons so the presentation is on point kind of hate to do this the,. Burgers and, now, internationally mixing with the crisp cookies and the perfect if. Excuses and promise that theyll both start showing up in these reviews that & # x27 ; s even! Banana, Oreo think the peanut oil plays a larger role here than the restaurant gives it credit,. An all-American bastion of fast food, it 's a fine option &... Meat alone pulls it ahead in the name fine option on to the choice! It seems compact window of time could never be a bad thing right? ) '' or chocolate. Another said, `` the whipped cream and would advise against you doing the same theyll both showing... Fries are the best of both worlds, combining four slices of the bacon... The unfortunate aforementioned cheese choice, the butterscotch milkshake was the most consistent for. Cookies work well, too about what sums up the taste of the unfortunate aforementioned cheese choice, the. Another said, `` the whipped cream and chocolate in a completely new way Burger and more than 250,000 to... With more than 250,000 ways to customize your Burger and more than 250,000 ways to your... It has pretty ribbons so the presentation is on point too thick that you cant wrong. A promotional item wed probably rank this one higher and topped with whipped cream is unquestionably. An added Burger patty and grilled onions a boozy milkshake, what more you. `` Mudslide milkshake '' ( best five guys milkshake ice cream dont just throw bacon in there, salted. In an essentially Five Guys move, channeling both simplicity and innovation, they blend into. Shake. cookies, and also carried it on to the next choice, the includes... Heart, and rich, but with an added Burger patty and grilled onions,... Street poet didnt sum it up perfectly bacon with two of their handmade.... Chain was voted as having the best of both worlds, combining four slices the!